In a message dated 7/11/2008 1:05:47 PM Central Daylight Time,
Brian.L.Jones@gsk.com writes:
> > My soldering is very bad plus I've been told that wiring in cars ought
> not be
> > soldered. Soldering does not allow minute vibrations of the connection
> thus
> > yielding broken wires.
>
> Is this urban myth, or is there truth to it?
>
Good question. As I like to say, you can prove anything you want with
anecdotal evidence. I suppose that some poorly executed wiring with soldered
connections have failed. But then I am sure that some poorly executed
non-soldered
connections have failed as well.
The two potential failure modes with soldered connections that come to mind
are:
1) residual flux causing corrosion, and
2) mechanical stress transfer to the end of the solder wicking.
The first on is the result of using acid flux and not washing the residue
away. (This has been touched on before) Rinsing can be problematic as it can
wick up the wires underneath the insulation where rinsing it out is not very
easy. Always us rosin or "No Clean" flux which leaves a benign residue.
The second is the result of the mechanical flexing of the harness
transmitting all the forces to the point where the solder, that has wicked into
the
strands, ends. This can cause stress hardening of the wires at that point and
fatigue will cause the wires to break. The preventative cure for this is to
secure the harness at a point close to the connection that will absorb the
mechanical forces and keep them from stressing the soldered part of the wire.
On a TR3, especially the early ones, there are a lot of connections that use
screws to clamp the wires to the terminal. In these types of connections a
tinned, stranded wire will act as a solid wire except that the lead/tin alloy
is
less resilient than is copper. That means that as the connection heats up
and cools down the compression forces will vary. If the force heats up enough
the lead/tin will flow (since it is malleable) and will permanently change
dimension. When it cools back down the connection forces are much reduced.
Copper will spring back to a greater degree than will lead/tin and will retain
connection pressure much better. This is the aluminum house wiring situation
from
the 60's all over again. One could (or should) retorque these connections on
an annual basis to stave off problems here.
Good, reliable wiring doesn't just happen, it is the result of attention to
detail. Just like everything else.
Dave
_______________________________________________
Support Team.Net http://www.team.net/donate.html
This list supported in part by the Vintage Triumph Register
http://www.vtr.org
Triumphs@autox.team.net
http://autox.team.net/mailman/listinfo/triumphs
http://www.team.net/archive
|