I thought the reason for black iron was the condensing capability of the
pipe, no?
Like you, I think that the threading, cutting, and sealing issues with
black iron are a huge pita, and copper is comparatively cake to
install. But if black iron is that much better at keeping the air dry,
well, I'm only going to do this once...
What say the list? Am I overstating the benefits of iron? Something
else to think about is that copper won't rust on the inside. There's
that...
On 10/17/2011 6:41 PM, Arvid Jedlicka wrote:
> A +1 on the ease of installation of copper.
>
> And at least in my area [Minnesota] the green-box store is about 10%
> cheaper on copper than the orange-box or the blue-box. I used "L" and
> a silver based solder and have never had an issue.
>
> I had tried black iron and found that Teflon tape is not the way to
> make an effective joint seal. I then went to Teflon pipe joint
> compound and that solved the pipe sealing issues but I was still left
> with the hassle of cutting and threading. So I started over with
> copper and like David have lived happily ever after.
>
> Arvid
|