mgs
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Quality (was: Re: Lowering)

To: REwald9535@aol.com
Subject: Re: Quality (was: Re: Lowering)
From: Jay and Mike Hartwig <mhartwig@cbu.edu>
Date: Fri, 01 Jan 1999 14:53:04 -0800

REwald9535@aol.com wrote:
> 
> I used to run a parts house so let me take a stab here.  Unfortunately in
> America, at least, the focus of most mechanics has gone from fixing cars to
> making money.  I used to get call from shops asking how much a clutch was for
> an MGB.  They would want all the prices separate.  He would then hang up and
> about 30 minutes later call up and order the cover and T/O from me.  What
> about the disk you ask?  He got that from the "Other Guy" because it was $1.00
> less!  Now don't tell me that he wasted far more than $1 in time making phone
> calls, I know that.  However, the companies that make and import auto parts
> want more market share, so they want lower prices.  There are only two ways to
> lower prices, one is to make more of a particular item and get economy of
> scale (ain't going to happen, the number of MG's on the road is going down not
> up), and two build a lower quality part that cost less to make.  Face it, we,
> the people that really want quality, are in the minority.

As I was helping my brother tune his Weber carbed '78 B, this exact
thing came to mind.  However lofty we place Moss and others, they are
still there to make a profit.  While I realize they do support the
enthusiast and are often times enthusiasts themselves, profit margins
prevail.  Believe me, this is not a flame of Moss as much as just an
observation.  My manilla file folder probably has at least $2500 in
parts from Moss alone ('70 B), and I don't even want to count how much
my receipts from Moss add up to on my previously owned '78 B.

> As far as the Porsche parts having better quality, well, you know the old joke
> about the difference between Porsches and porcupines?  Porsche owners and
> mechanics won't stand for anything less then factory quality.  The people that
> make P parts know this and jack up their prices accordingly.

True; the Crane box I got from Summit Racing was only $150.  From a
Porsche parts house, it was over $300.  As far as the comment about
factory quality: I'd much rather pay $30 for an OEM quality window sill
scraper for the P-car, versus pay $10 for my piece of sh*t window sill
scraper for my MGB that is cracking after only two years.  Many of the
parts on my P-car, particularly in the interior are original and in good
condition.  The car was not even taken care of particularly well.

Being an engineer, of course, I am gaga over the fit/finish and quality
of the P-car.  Doesn't mean I don't like the MGB.  SOMETIMES I just like
something that accelerates faster than a '86 Dodge Caravan. :)

jay

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>