triumphs
[Top] [All Lists]

The latest brouhaha about VTR...

To: triumphs@autox.team.net
Subject: The latest brouhaha about VTR...
From: Michael Porter <portermd@zianet.com>
Date: Thu, 26 May 2005 01:14:16 -0600
.. and elitism. I have a few comments.

When John McCartney and I conspired to contrive a prize in honor of his 
father, the "Daily Driver" prize, the board of the VTR fought it, and 
the chief judge of that organization sought to turn it into a concours 
category prize. I, and John, wanted it to go to the fellow who kept his 
car on the road, no matter what. The chief judge of the VTR thought 
otherwise. I went to the 2001 VTR convention with the express intention 
to find that daily driver and award that prize. I sat in the audience at 
the final award dinner, dumbfounded, when the VTR and the hosting club 
ignored that prize, even though all were aware of it beforehand.

The chief judge of the VTR has spent more than enough time on this board 
talking about his very expensive brick garage in which he keeps his 
various rare Triumphs, and the president has offered up photos of his 
garage, full of memorabilia, acquired with the proceeds from his businesses.

Ultimately, when I and others describe the elitism in the hobby, it is 
of this we speak, in one way or another. When the word "elitism" is 
mentioned, it is an analogue for exclusivity. Some people in this sport, 
hobby, whatever, choose to make their wealth apparent to others through 
their acquisitions.

At the VTR national in 2001, it was good that Vern brought his LeMans 
Spitfire. But, he wouldn't even start it up for the crowd, nor would he 
run it in the autocross. I was there, and he didn't.  Vern, like many 
other members of the VTR, is into acquiring things, not using them. I 
spent my time there helping to tune Joe Curry's Spit autocrosser so he 
could run the course (because the idiots in the Rocky Mountain club 
thought that holding an event at 10,000 ft. altitude wouldn't 
inconvenience anyone). Vern opted to leave his car for display. I didn't 
see Vern rejetting and tuning so he could run....

This hobby--and the leadership of VTR--has been run by and lately 
controlled by people who don't care about driving their cars every 
day--they care about their acquisitions--about displaying the icons of 
their wealth. They care about showing others the objects indicating 
their wealth.

That is why the VTR continues to lose membership over the years--it has 
become not a club, but a clique. That's a fact, now, rather than an 
eventuality to come. The VTR really doesn't give a shit about Triumph 
drivers--it cares about Triumph owners.

Ultimately, what is wrong with the VTR is what's wrong with the country. 
  Possession is more important than use and utility. As John McCartney 
has said, repeatedly, the cars were meant to be used and enjoyed, and 
are, in their engineering, neither sophisticated nor elegant--the cars 
were and are mid-line objects meant to be driven and enjoyed for what 
they were and are, and no more. Creating a club structure which would 
make them into icons of what they are not is ridiculous.

The VTR is losing members because it has become stilted and 
self-important--and elitist.  The people running the VTR don't recognize 
that fact. They will ruin their organization from within, because they 
think they are more important to the hobby and sport than the people who 
drive their cars every day.

The proof is in the pudding (an old English saying). Your membership 
continues to decline, because you continue to deny addressing the truth, 
and it's a mystery to all of you in the leadership of the organization 
why you lose members. It's a mystery to you because you simply won't, or 
can't, accept the truth that what you want is not what everyone else wants.

Get real, guys. Dig your heads out of your asses and stop being quite so 
self-important. You are impeding the sport and the hobby, and you're 
doing so because you haven't yet figured out the joy in the hobby. You 
still think _having_ something is more important than enjoying it by 
driving it.

VTR? Its leaders are silly, stupid, self-important people who put their 
own importance over the hobby.

Give me a break, guys.


-- 
Never let anyone drive you crazy when you know it's within walking 
distance....




<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>