6pack
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Engine re-build must-do's

To: Michael Lupynec <mlupynec@globalserve.net>
Subject: Re: Engine re-build must-do's
From: "Robert M. Lang" <lang@isis.mit.edu>
Date: Fri, 13 Sep 2002 12:20:01 -0400 (EDT)
On Fri, 13 Sep 2002, Michael Lupynec wrote:

> Has anybody mentioned boring and going to the next oversize
> pistons? If you are rebuilding an engine you will rarely find the
> current pistons within factory new spec.

I will not disagree that worn pistons should be replaced. But once again,
don't assume that you need to replace them as a matter of course. I have a
set in my street car now with about 130K miles on them and the bores are
still round and the pistons have negligible "scuffing" on them. I
re-ringed the motor last winter and honed the cylinders. Next time, for
sure, I'll have to go oversize, but at the current rate of usage, I could
get 300,000+ miles from the block by doing reborees in .010 increments. 
 
> And if it's typically within wear limits why do up a rebuild with
> a half life on reliability and good tune?

What's half the life? 20k miles? 50k miles?

Most folks with these cars put maybe 3000 miles a years on them. Do the
math. A rebuild with new pistons has a return on investment of practically
ZERO. We're talking $300 for pistons and then another $300 for a bore/hone
and then (theorectically a balance job - maybe another $250 or more). So
you spend $1k when you could have merely re-ringed the pistons ($50).

I took the initial message to indicate that the person wanted to know
_what must I absolutely do?_, not how many things can I replace on my
motor.

It turns out that this topic is a hot-button for me. Too many folks go out
and do _everything_ to thier motor when in fact they don't really need
to. But heck - it's your money... spend it as you wish.

> Mike L
> 60A,67E,59Bug,74TR6

regards,
rml
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bob Lang              Room N42-140Q            |  This space for rent
Consultant            MIT unix-vms-help        |
Voice:617-253-7438    FAX: 617-258-9535        |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>